Showing posts with label foreign policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label foreign policy. Show all posts

Monday, March 24, 2008

The Obama Doctrine

The Obama Doctrine - Spencer Ackerman @ The American Prospect

This article from the latest issue of the American Prospect is an examination of the meaning behind Sen. Obama's remark during a debate that we not only need to end the war in Iraq but "end the mind-set that got us into war in the first place." Basing his article around this statement, Ackerman interviewed many of the foreign policy team the Obama campaign has put together and questioned them on what a President Obama would do to change the U.S.'s foreign policy and how his vision of American foreign affairs differs from that of Sen. Clinton or Sen. McCain, not to mention President Bush himself. The consensus is that versus taking a democracy-promotion approach a President Obama would take a dignity-promotion approach. What that means is not simply holding free elections but providing the basic underlying infrastruture for a democratic election to actually mean something.
It's an approach that many liberals and commentators have long called for, including Ackerman's close associate Matt Yglesias and the relatively recently converted Andrew Sullivan. What this approach entails is bringing the best the U.S. has to offer in refugee relief, ending dictitorial regimes that prevent such relief, and providing the necessary aid to oppressed peoples that they feel secure enough to either call for elections or bring about their own uprising. Instead of simply offering elections, an Obama presidency would press the issue of human rights, and if you've heard his policy position on free trade, you can see that the human rights issue is a top priority for Sen. Obama.
I believe I've argued before that a foreign policy focused on human rights does more to protect the image of America as the shining city on the hill (which gives us a good deal of legitimacy when we do act) and allow us the freedom to act in regions and in ways that do not conform to standard diplomatic tactics. Sen. Obama's thinking on this isssue rises to the strategic level. The human rights card is available for almost any kind of foreign issue: global warming, labor rights, diplomacy, foreign aid (both monetary and basic food and medical supplies) and, importantly, as a way of pushing 'rogue states' or generally states that have decided to play their own games in their regions of the world to fall in line with U.S. interests or at the very least UN mandates.
Now this might have a touch of American exceptionalism in it, but Sen. Obama's attitude over foreign relations marks a departure from previous administrations unwilling to use military and diplomatic power appropriately. While the need to maintain a large military with full battle gear is necessary the use of Special Forces will certainly rise in an Obama administration. His remarks on Pakistan show his willingness to use military force when certain objectives require it. But it also become a genuine stick to lay in front of troublesome nations while offering a genuine alternative that avoids military confrontation.
In deciding between the remaining three candidates for president it is clear that Sen. Obama is the only one who is offering a real foreign policy and one that attempts to show the best of American power. It's a Teddy Roosevelt style policy of speaking softly but carrying a big stick. Our actions must do more to prevent radicalism from spreading than simply fighting the radicals that already exist. It's a foreign policy that I can support with confidence, particularly coming from a new generation of Democrats unafraid of the Republican attack machines.

Monday, February 25, 2008

Being a Grammar Nazi

Clinton: Obama is to Foreign Policy as Bush was to Foreign Policy - Marc Ambinder

“We’ve seen the tragic results of having a president who didn’t have neither the experience nor the wisdom to manage our foreign policy and safeguard our national security. We can’t let that happen again.”

Now I'm not one to nit-pick (actually, I am) but the first sentence is really bad: "didn't have neither"? I can understand when giving speeches one can get their words a little mixed up but for someone like Sen. Clinton to make a freshman mistake like that is just silly.
On a more serious note, Sen. Clinton just made it easier on Sen. McCain on the national security front. If an election between Sens. Clinton and McCain was decided solely on foreign policy experience alone then Sen. Clinton would find herself beaten a foot into the ground by Sen. McCain. It's simply stupid of her to go on the attack on foreign policy when she doesn't have much of one and to claim experience in the matter when she will face a giant in the public's mind on national security.

One-Armed Political Fighting

The Foreign Policy Failure - Matt Yglesias

Yglesias makes a salient point here concerning the foreign policy positions of the two Democratic candidates. Sen. Obama has made it clear for some time now that he has put together a serious and dramatically different foreign policy than Sen. Clinton, who has attempted to avoid any deep probing of the issue. More than just the issue of meeting with our enemies are the issues of weapons technology and nuclear stockpiles. Yet the mainstream media has failed to grapple with the issue in any real way, most conspicuously in the arena of op-ed pieces. Yglesias points out that in the case of the Washington Post their op-ed staff lack someone who would tackle the foreign policy issue of the Democratic candidates in anything approaching even-handedness.
This lack of attention becomes a problem for the candidates, most particularly Sen. Obama, when their is little distinction between their domestic agendas. While Yglesias makes the point that the president has a greater freedom of movement in the foreign policy arena, I think the more important point is that the lack of foreign policy discussion has allowed not only Sen. Clinton to avoid any serious embarrassment during a debate, it has allowed Sen. McCain the opportunity to go unopposed when he turns his attention to foreign policy in his speeches. For a presumptive front-runner like Sen. Obama to have half of his entire policy agenda ignored is strange and potentially harmful when it comes to countering Sen. McCain's policy points. Outside of the regular blog readers, the majority of the public has little in the way to assess Sen. Obama on national security, an important issue for many still.

Thursday, January 31, 2008

A Stooge for a Stage

Your Pretty Face is Going to Hell - Spencer Ackerman

Foreign policy wonk, Spencer Ackerman, makes a pretty convincing argument that Sen. Obama won tonight's debate based on his position on the Iraq war combined with Sen. Clinton's bumbling response. Money quote: I don't know how a single Democratic voter watches that exchange and thinks, "Yeah, I'm gonna vote for Hillary Clinton! The war was a tough call and maybe it wasn't a mistake, but it's a mistake now!"